Followers

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

The Marquis Who Would Not Bend

Bend but don't break? This installment profiles one of the lesser-known but intriguing foreign officers who served the American cause, and one who makes an intriguing cameo in my novel, The South Spy, during the pivotal action of his very controversial life in uniform.

A Cavalier from the Islands

The hot-headed French officer arrived in the autumn of 1776 with salt still in his boots and a French commission in his pocket. François Lellorquis de Malmédy, self-styled Marquis, had crossed from French Martinique as a sous-lieutenant of cavalry.

Young Sous-Lieutenant Arrives in America


The blood of the Gray clan ran in him—descended from an old Scottish family named Gray (or de Gray) that had migrated to France generations earlier. Washington’s officers met a man who bowed with perfect grace and then argued rank before the wine was poured—immediately demanding that he be made a general. Washington’s deputy commander, Major General Charles Lee, never one to mince words, warned that the newcomer’s temper was hot. They took him anyway.

Earthworks and Ambition

But his time came. By September 1776, Rhode Island named him a brigadier and chief engineer of the militia, even as the British fleet still loomed off Newport. Through the bitter months of 1776–77, Malmédy drove militia crews to raise batteries and dig lines. In May 1777, Congress gave him “only” a colonel’s commission in the Continental Army—he balked, writing Washington at once. The letter was polite, but the complaint was not—protesting that the rank fell below his merit. The Commander-in-Chief noted the officer’s courage and filed the request away. Malmédy rode south still wearing the rank he considered an insult.

Oppressive Heat of Battle

At the Battle of Monmouth on June twenty-eight, 1778, the Marquis de Malmédy played a direct and hazardous role right in the eye of the storm, amid musket fire and cannonballs as hot as the sun. Serving as a military adviser and staff officer to Major General Charles Lee, Malmédy led part of the elite advance corps tasked with striking Sir Henry Clinton’s retreating British column. But the situation turned sharply against the vanguard, and he was swept up in Lee’s indecision and the rout that mortified Lee and the commander-in-chief. A battle won became a draw, and some taint resulted.

Washington Confronts Lee at Monmouth 
by Mark Maritato

Smoke at Stono

Afterward, the French colonel drifted south, seeking to put the affair at Monmouth behind him and, of course, a command commensurate with his ambition. On a June morning in 1779, he led the light infantry on the American flank at Stono Ferry, South Carolina. The British came on hard through the marsh. But Malmédy’s company held the hinge while the main line bent and recovered. After the guns fell silent, he cleaned his sword and asked for a larger command. For after all, he had once more proven his mettle. The answer, as always, was not the one he wanted.

Stono Ferry


 

Hold Lemire’s Point

When General Henry Clinton’s army sealed off beleaguered Charleston in 1780, Lincoln tasked the French colonel with keeping the Cooper River open, the key line of communication to the interior. Malmédy led two hundred North Carolina militia to Lempriere’s Point and Cainhoy. Under his meticulous engineer’s eye, they dug defensive positions and mounted guns dragged from Fort Moultrie.

Defending Providence


British Major Patrick Ferguson—commanding his specialized corps of provincial troops (the American Volunteers) alongside loyalist units—was dispatched to sever that escape route. On April 19, Malmédy’s men drove Ferguson’s probe back into the woods. But Ferguson was indomitable—the net would soon be closed.


The Better Part of Valor

On May 2, 1780, Ferguson launched a sharp, aggressive push toward Mount Pleasant and the Lempriere’s Point / Haddrell's Point area. His Loyalist forces stormed and captured the American redoubts and outposts guarding the area. Malmédy realized his position was hopeless. Instead of holding out to the last man or waiting to be cornered, he decided to spike the guns, scramble into boats, and withdraw his men to safety across the Cooper River. By evacuating across the river, Malmédy and his immediate men avoided being trapped inside the city.

Abandoning Lempriere's Point


Incensed that the hinge protecting Charleston was too easily abandoned, General Benjamin Lincoln threatened a court-martial. But Malmédy was already gone, one of the few senior officers who never set foot in a British prison after the city’s fall. The one time he did bend, he never fully shook off the taint, but his move likely kept even more valuable troops from marching off to the British prison hulks in New York. How do you say, “discretion is the better part of valor,” a Francaise?

Gallantry at the Springs

By the summer of 1781, he had clashed with the Southern Theater’s new commander, General Nathanael Greene, as freely as he had with Washington and Lincoln. Greene, practical to the bone, sent him north for militia and powder. Malmédy returned with enough men to stand in the center of the line at Eutaw Springs. 

Clash at Eutaw Springs


On the eighth of September, the crimson waves of the British came through the open fields and wooded ravines. Malmédy’s North Carolinians—militia and light dragoons—stood and fought until the ground was carpeted red. Greene later wrote of the Frenchman’s “great gallantry and good conduct.” For one afternoon, the restless colonel had been exactly where he always claimed he belonged.

Friction the High Hills

Afterward, Greene rested his army on the sandy ridges above the Santee River, known as The High Hills. There, in the sultry cantonment, the old quarrel with Major Smith Snead of Virginia finally came to an end.

General Nathanael Greene 


By the time the two officers met at The High Hills of Santee in the fading autumn of 1781, they had already endured the long, bitter lessons of the Southern war. Months of short rations, frayed nerves, and endless camp arguments over precedence and command had transformed what had begun as ordinary professional friction into a cold, personal hatred neither man would set aside. Their old grievances found room to fester. A lingering quarrel over honor finally crossed the line from angry words to a formal challenge.

Code Duello at Dawn

On a clear November dawn, with seconds in attendance and the pale autumn sky overhead, the two men faced each other at pistol range. Following the era’s Code Duello, they took an agreed number of steps, turned, lowered their pistols, and fired. Only Snead’s ball struck true. Blood staining his white shirt red, Malmédy tumbled into the wet grass, his turbulent career ended in an instant by a fellow officer rather than by the enemy he had fought for years.

Code Duello at Dawn


General Nathanael Greene, already worn thin by the task of holding a quarrelsome officer corps together, could only mourn the waste. He condemned the affair as another example of “that stupid custom which had already cost the army far too many useful men.” Malmédy was buried somewhere in Sumter County soil, the final act of a man who had never learned to yield.

Notes on a Difficult Ally

In the annals of the Revolution, François de Malmédy remains a minor yet vivid figure—brave, skilled, and impossible to command. From Rhode Island ditches to the palmetto flats, he served the cause he had crossed an ocean to find. The same pride that drove him also finished him. Washington’s officers remembered the heat of his temper. Greene remembered the steadiness of his line at Eutaw. Between those two recollections lies the short, restless career of the Marquis de Malmédy.

Unlike the more famous Malmédy massacre of frightened green soldiers at the Battle of the Bulge, this was a massacre of a single brave but headstrong officer. Ironically, in the end, the code of honor he cherished proved more fatal than any British musket volley.

 

No comments:

Post a Comment