Clan Mother

The Clandestine Challenge

The difficulty with any espionage study is the lack of unclassified sources — since clandestine work must remain secret by nature. This is especially true when looking back to the time of the Yankee Doodle spies, when nearly all espionage activity was "off the books," with few reports or records kept. Spies operated in all theaters throughout the war, but identifying who they were and what they did is difficult, requiring lots of "fill in the blank" and connect-the-dots analysis.

Spying on the Spies

Savage War of Peace

The American Revolution in the Mohawk Valley involved years of internecine conflict and small-scale combat that often reached a fever pitch. Patriot Whigs and Loyalist Tories went head to head in battles ranging from a few dozen to a few hundred fighters, rarely involving large-scale clashes with thousands. Add six Iroquois tribes, Canadians, Continentals, and British regulars into the mix, and you get a stew of conflict and chaos. But unlike many other areas of the war, the central New York region was never quiet. Instead, a relentless savage war of peace raged on. 

The Mohawk Valley

The role of the native tribes added an objective layer of complexity to the struggle in New York. The powerful Iroquois Confederacy was mostly aligned with the British, thanks to the outstanding efforts of the Crown's Indian Agent, Sir William Johnson, and his son. 

Sir William Johnson

Of the Iroquois nations, the most powerful, warlike, and pro-British were the Mohawks, who controlled the easternmost part of the territory. Our subject is one of those Mohawks, a woman born Konwatsi'tsiaiénni, but now known as Mary or Molly Brant, older sister to Joseph Brant, who became a Mohawk War Chief and British officer during the war for independence. 

Youth in Two Worlds

Molly Brant was born around 1736 in the Ohio Valley, although her family's ancestral home was the village of Canajoharie, on the upper Mohawk near Little Falls, New York. Her parents were Margaret (Onagsakearat) and Peter (Tehowaghwengaraghkwin), who were Anglicans. When Peter died while the family lived on the Ohio River, Molly's mother returned to Canajoharie with her and her brother Joseph.

Iroquois Village

Both Brant children grew up in two worlds, becoming fluent in English and comfortable with English culture. Molly was educated in the Mohawk Valley, and because she spoke English well, she accompanied twelve Mohawk tribal elders on a delegation to Philadelphia in 1755. After that trip, Molly met the most powerful man in these two worlds, the renowned British Indian Agent Sir William Johnson — her beauty and grace deeply affected him. Johnson handled all the deals involving the tribes and was known to be an honest broker who cared for both the Iroquois and the white settlers in central New York. He was also quite wealthy.

Lady of the Manor

By 1759, the twenty-three-year-old Molly was officially listed in Johnson's records as his "housekeeper," but she was, in fact, his common-law wife—possibly married under Iroquois customs. She would have seven children with him and served in all respects as the powerful Johnson's partner. 

Molly Brant was the Lady of Johnson Hall

Anglo visitors who visited Johnson's estate, Johnson Hall, remarked on her beauty, delicate features, olive skin, excellent manners, and understated but commanding presence. In all but name, Brant was the Lady of the  Johnson Hall estate.

The Clan Mother

During her time with Johnson, she also rose to become a Clan Mother, receiving the Mohawk name Tekonwatonti (Many Opposed to One). Molly led a society of Six Nations (Iroquois Confederacy) matrons. In the matriarchal hierarchy of the Iroquois, Clan Mothers held great power and influence, traditionally choosing and dismissing leaders. They also had the authority to veto their decisions.

Clan Mothers wielded significant influence

Sir William died the year before Lexington and Concord erupted and plunged the colonies into open war with the Crown. 

Loyal to the Crown

Molly Brant and her brother Joseph remained loyalists, dedicated to the British cause. Joseph became a well-known Loyalist commander and Mohawk War Chief whose actions frustrated the patriots. 

Chief Joseph Brant

His sister's role was more ambiguous but equally important. She provided food and ammunition to nearby Loyalist units. Most importantly, she passed valuable intelligence to her brother and other Loyalist and British leaders in central New York. 

Spymaster

Although there's little recorded about this (for reasons mentioned above), she probably heard reports on American movements in the Mohawk Valley from travelers, hunters, and traders passing through her village.

Molly Brant: Mother Clan, Mother.Spy

The best example of this occurred in August 1777. British Lieutenant-Colonel Barry St. Leger's force, composed of British troops, Loyalists, Canadians, and Indians, had besieged the American garrison at Fort Stanwix (located in today5s Rome, NY). When the Tryon County militia learned of the siege, a brigade-sized force marched west along the river to relieve the post.

Battle of Oriskany

When Molly learned of their movement, she sent word to St. Leger, who dispatched a force of Loyalists and Indian allies that set a well-planned ambush in the dense cypress forests near Oriskany. The relief column was pushed back with heavy losses, and its commander, Colonel Nikolas Herkimer, was mortally wounded.

Fort Stanwix

In retaliation, the American-Allied Oneidas attacked her village of Canajoharie, destroying it and nearby Fort Hunter. 

On the Road

Molly moved her family through various Loyal Iroquois villages. Brant and her family lost most of their belongings. They sought refuge at Onondaga near Syracuse, New York, the capital of the Six Nations Confederacy, first going to Syracuse, then Cayuga, and finally Niagara.

Iroquois Village along the Mohawk River

At each of these, she proved to be a strong and effective supporter of the Loyalist cause, helping to keep most of the Iroquois aligned with the British. As a result, the British were able to use the Iroquois war bands to strengthen their diminishing Loyalist and British forces in New York.

Iroquois War Band

Resilient Leader

As the war continued in New York, the British and their Indian allies were gradually pushed westward. The British asked Molly Brant to help lead the thousands of starving refugees fleeing the Americans to the safety of Fort Niagara — the last stronghold in the area. She proved to be a capable leader, organizer, and spokesperson for the tribes. Her influence and power grew among both the tribes and the British authorities.

Fort Niagra: last bastion of British 

power in New York

One British officer remarked that her influence on the tribes was such that "their uncommon good behaviour in great measure to be ascribed to Miss Molly Brant's influence over them, which [was] far superior to that of all their Chiefs put together."

A Separate Peace

But when the Treaty of Paris was signed, the rug was pulled out from under the Iroquois and Loyalists in New York. The British made little effort to protect their ancestral lands, leaving the Iroquois to face their enemies alone — and it did not go well. Many of the Iroquois and all the Loyalists fled to Canada. 

Treaty of Paris signing

A Bitter Nation

The Iroquois who stayed behind became bitter toward Molly and her British masters. Molly left the home the British built for her on Carleton Island, as it was now on the American side of the border. The Clan Mother moved to a village called Cataraqui and, with other Loyalists, founded what later became Kingston, Ontario.

A Grateful Crown

The grateful British awarded her land and a pension large enough to turn down the Americans' offers to return to New York. They recognized her leadership's importance. But she was dismissive of the people who had destroyed the Iroquois lands during eight years of bloody warfare.

Founding Canadian

Molly Brant's family became well-known in Upper Canada. Five of her six daughters married Canadian men. George, her surviving son, got a position in the Indian department. Her older son died fighting for the British. 

At age sixty, the Clan Mother died in Brantford, Ontario, in 1796. Her exact burial site is unknown, but many believe the good, lifelong Anglican rests somewhere beneath St. Paul's Church in today's Kingston, Ontario, Canada. Her legacy is that of a remarkable woman who cared for her family, clan, tribe, and nation in both peace and war.

St. Paul's Church and Burial Ground

The Governor-General

 Center Stage

Another profile of a historical character in my fourth Yankee Doodle Spies novel, The North Spy, features a British officer who played a unique role in shaping North America's destiny. Our character's political intrigue greatly influences the series of events that unfold in the action novel.

Yankee Doodle Spies

Another Irish Soldier

Guy Carleton was born on September 3, 1724, in Strabane, Ireland. He was the son of a Protestant landowner. However, he was at ease with the Roman Catholics in the local community and did not develop the same prejudices as most of his peers. Carleton received a commission in the British Army at age 18 as an ensign in the 25th Regiment of Foot. He was promoted to Lieutenant two years later and fought in the Jacobite Uprising in Scotland and the War of the Austrian Succession in Europe.

British Infantry mid 18th Century

The Guards and Patronage

In 1751, he joined the 1st Foot Guards, and in 1752, he was promoted to captain. Carleton used strong connections with notable figures like James Wolfe and the Duke of Richmond. In 1757, Carleton was promoted to lieutenant colonel and served in Germany. In 1758, he was named the lieutenant colonel of the newly formed 72nd Regiment of Foot. 

Guards Officer with Halberd

Fighting the French & Indians & Spanish

He saw extensive action during the French and Indian War. He led an elite battalion of 600 grenadiers under now Major General James Wolfe at the Battle of Quebec, which led to the conquest of New France. After recovering from a serious head wound at Quebec, he served at Belle Isle, France, and as a colonel in Havana, Cuba, where he was wounded again in battle. Interestingly, he fought alongside Richard Montgomery, a well-known British officer who would later become his enemy.

British infantry routing the French on the Plains of Abraham

Managing Quebec

By 1766, Carleton had returned to Quebec as its Lieutenant-Governor. Quebec was a French-speaking Catholic colony, and effectively governing it required all the skills and finesse that Carleton could bring. He won over the residents with initiatives aimed at ensuring religious and political freedoms. He cultivated relationships with the elites and soon gained their support for British rule.  

Lord Dunmore

However, conflicts with the Governor-General, John Murray, Earl of Dunmore, over the best ways to administer the new land, led to his return to London. This trip would prove to be very beneficial for him. Later, Lord Dunmore served as governor in North Carolina and then Virginia. The Scotsman's aggressive attitude helped push both colonies toward rebellion.

Promotion and Eros

On May 22, 1772, nearly 48 years old, Carleton married Lady Maria Howard, the daughter of Thomas Howard, 2nd Earl of Effingham. They had nine sons and two daughters. While he was in London, Parliament passed the Quebec Act of 1774, mainly based on his recommendations. This act defined how the province was governed, guaranteed religious freedom, and expanded Canada's colonial territory down the Mississippi River. Unfortunately, these measures put Britain on a collision course with the Protestant and expansionist thirteen colonies. 

The Quebec Act was a far-sighted policy

Governor-General

Major General Guy Carleton returned to Canada as Quebec's Governor-General in 1774 to find the 13 seaboard colonies embroiled in political unrest and rebellion.

General Guy Carleton

The outbreak of full rebellion by the New England colonies in 1775 had an immediate effect on Carleton's Quebec. The British commander-in-chief in North America, General Thomas Gage, took 800 British regulars from him to defend Boston. The local French did not rally in large numbers to support his militia forces, and he refused calls to enlist the native tribes.

Thomas Gage

Invasion and War

Thus weakened, he was unprepared for the winter assault launched by the American invasion in the fall of 1775. Two of America's best commanders, General Richard Montgomery and Colonel Benedict Arnold, led bold advances across two fronts.

General Montgomery marshals his troops to invade Canada

Fortunately, the Americans' poor timing, insufficient supplies, and worsening weather hindered what appeared to be an imminent and quick victory.

Stout Defender

Guy Carleton also showed true courage in his own right. He carried out a defensive action that slowed Montgomery's push on Montreal, trading space for time. The besieged governor managed to hold out for a while in Montreal but nearly fell into rebel hands during his evacuation—determined to continue his defense further down the Saint Lawrence River at Quebec City, where he would make a last-ditch stand. 

Quebec

With Arnold now in front of Quebec and Montgomery ready to join him, Carleton counted on three factors: the arrival of winter, the bravery of his small group of regulars and provincials, and reinforcements from Britain. Miraculously for him, all three came together, but not without significant effort and sacrifice. 

Benedict Arnold

The Americans' full-scale attack on Quebec failed due to severe weather, a resilient and steadfast defense, and effective tactical choices. General Montgomery was mortally wounded in the blinding snowstorm that swirled around the city. Colonel Arnold was hit in the leg by a musket ball, and the British captured several American leaders, including Dan Morgan and Ethan Allen. Carleton remained strong against a weak American army scattered throughout the city until General John Burgoyne arrived in March 1776. 

Failed assault on Quebec

Counter Stroke

With new troops reinforcing him, Carleton launched a counterattack. In June, his devastating strike against acting American commander General John Sullivan at Trois Rivieres caused the scattered and poorly supplied Americans to retreat back into New York.

Canadian Militia at Trois-Rivieres

Carleton then went on the offensive. Over the next few months, he built a fleet and launched it down Lake Champlain in October 1776. However, Colonel, now Brigadier-General Arnold, had recovered and stayed busy assembling a fleet of his own. The two clashed at Valcour Island on October 10. Arnold fought a clever battle and inflicted losses on the British fleet before Carleton decisively defeated him. The route to Albany and deep into the rebel heartland was now open.

Valcour Island

But the Governor-General had second thoughts about continuing a new campaign so late in the season. He withdrew north to strengthen his supply line and prepare for a final push the next season. It was a season that would not belong to him. Carleton's hesitancy in 1776 caused London to "go in a different direction."

A Different Direction

While the Americans used the winter break to regroup and strengthen their hold on Lake Champlain, General Burgoyne returned to Britain. He convinced Lord George Germain and King George to appoint him as commander of the new army and to lead the spring offensive into New York. Carleton responded by resigning as Governor-General and returning to Britain as the governor of Armagh, Ireland. 

John Burgoyne

Military Disaster

Meanwhile, Burgoyne's defeat and surrender to the Americans at Saratoga in October 1777 triggered a series of events that drew France and Spain into the fight against Britain. After Cornwallis surrendered at Yorktown in October 1781, the British realized they needed to deal with what appeared to be their defeat in America. 

Surrender at Yorktown

Managing Defeat

With the signing of the Treaty of Paris, London recalled General Henry Clinton and sent Carleton to replace him as commander-in-chief in North America. His role was to oversee the aftermath of defeat by enforcing the terms of the peace treaty. Carleton ensured an orderly process and advocated for the rights and interests of the remaining Loyalists and British supporters of former slaves in the colonies. He refused to evacuate the last British garrison in New York until all Loyalist refugees were safely settled in Québec and Nova Scotia. 

The British departed New York City in 1783

The Peer

In 1783, he was named the 1st Baron Dorchester when he returned to England. However, London once again needed his administrative skills in North America. In 1786, he went back for another term as Governor-in-Chief of North America – Canada and the various maritime provinces.

Governor-in-Chief

He focused on the economic growth of the colonies. To achieve this, he deliberately misinterpreted the British ban on American imports to promote trade with the American West. The ban would only affect seaports. 

1st Baron Dorchester

Carleton played a key role in splitting the colony into Upper Canada (Ontario) and Lower Canada (Quebec), each with its own assembly, and he outlined the plan for British control over all its North American territories.

Carlton's Canada

To England's Green Pastures

On July 9, 1796, Carleton sailed from Canada to Britain, never to return. He died suddenly on November 10, 1808, at Stubbings House in Burchett's Green near Maidenhead, England. Guy Carleton, Lord Dorchester, was buried in the parish church of St. Swithun's, Nately Scures.

Carleton in Winter

Lasting Legacy

Although he was a skilled combat leader, Carleton's legacy centers on his abilities as an administrator—someone capable of organizing and managing in times of peace, crisis, and war. His talents helped bring the eight-year American War for Independence to a respectful close and also contributed to building the future Dominion of Canada. Both achievements demonstrate his status as a great leader who left a significant impact on the future of North America.

Carleton Memorial

First to Fall Part 2: First Hero

Autumn Winds

Brigadier General Richard Montgomery tugged at his leather glove as the line of poorly fed and poorly armed men marched northward. The winds were strengthening, and the skies looked like slate. His eyes shifted to the dense forests to the north – Canada. We must strike quickly, or these lads will leave their bones here. 

Brigadier General Richard Montgomery

Isle of Hope

On September 4th, Schuyler joined Montgomery with an additional 800 men. Now, he had 2,000 poorly trained and poorly equipped soldiers. Schuyler was also ill. Despite this, the aging New Yorker ordered the army to move toward a small island on the Richelieu River called Île aux Noix. With little time left, on September 6th, Montgomery led a force north to their first goal, Fort St. John's, which protected the route to Montreal. Paddles and oars brushed the dark waters, each stroke bringing the army and Montgomery closer to their destiny. They carried more than just bullets in their pouches. Schuyler, who was in poor health and unable to lead the expedition, had drafted a proclamation calling the Canadians "Friends and Countrymen" and pleading for their support in driving the British out of the territory. They would be disappointed in this hope. Montgomery’s probing attack failed. Although he managed to repel an ambush of about 100 Indians under Captain Matthew Mead, Schuyler feared the fort couldn't be taken by storm and ordered Montgomery to return to the island, which the Americans then fortified.

Area of Operations around Montreal

Fort St. Johns 

Montgomery decided to make another attempt at Fort St. Johns, but this attack was no more successful. In a series of errors, the two pincers of the American assault collided in the dark, muddy woods. Each thought they had encountered the British, and both forces fled. A furious Montgomery was able to stop the retreat and redirect them toward the fort.

His men advanced under withering British grapeshot fire, and the assault on the British breastworks was driven back. Montgomery planned another attack on the fort. However, half the New England troops fled. Montgomery, believing his force could no longer take the fort, retreated to Île aux Noix. When Schuyler’s illness forced him to return to Fort Ticonderoga, command of the late-start and ill-equipped operation was now his.

On September 16, Montgomery launched another expedition against the British fort. This time, he had 1,400 men along with a naval component consisting of two small ships and ten bateaux carrying 350 troops. The bateaux would counter the HMS Royal Savage. Montgomery arrived with the main force the following day. A month-long siege began, with the defenders outmanned and the attackers outgunned. The British garrison of 725 men was commanded by Major Charles Preston, who had been Montgomery's superior officer in the British Army just three years earlier. After initial skirmishing, Montgomery proceeded to besiege the fort. Progress was slow. Montgomery was everywhere at once, encouraging the building of siege lines and often coming under fire himself. 

                                                                        Fort St. John

On September 22, the fiery general was inspecting the breastworks when a cannon shot from the fort flew by, tearing his coattails and causing him to tumble down. By luck and skill, Montgomery managed to land on his feet. His men watched and were all impressed by his Sang Froid. Their commander was a man of steel nerves. However, by early October, they still had not closed the ring on the fort, despite bringing in more guns. One battery did sink HMS Royal Savage, but Montgomery’s forces remained outgunned in most areas. 

In mid-October, James Livingston, a relative of Janet Montgomery, recommended that Montgomery attempt to attack nearby Fort Chambly, which was a weaker post than St. John. He agreed and launched a night assault ten miles down the river. In two days, the fort surrendered 83 men and a large amount of valuable powder. However, the most significant prize was the colors of the 7th Royal Fusiliers, which he sent to the bedridden Schuyler – marking the first time a British battle flag fell into American hands.

The King's Colors of the 7th Royal Fusiliers

This boosted morale, and Montgomery was able to get his men to reinforce the defenses around Fort St. John. They also managed to repel a relief force sent from Montreal by General Guy Carleton, the British commander in Canada. By November 1st, the new batteries positioned north of the fort completed the encirclement. They launched a bombardment that shattered walls and buildings, causing little damage but significantly lowering the defenders' morale. As night fell on the battlefield, Montgomery ordered a cease-fire and sent a flag of truce. During the night, the Americans intercepted a dispatch from Carleton instructing Major Preston to continue his defense. The following day, the fort surrendered with full military honors, and its garrison marched off to imprisonment. One can't help but wonder what might have happened if the message had gone through. 

Montreal

Montgomery’s first major victory was now within his reach. But the weather and the terrain proved to be tough allies for the British. His men trudged across rugged ground covered with ice and snow. An early winter storm made progress even harder. He encouraged his men forward, knowing Carleton and his army were nearly cornered. When he learned of a British attempt to escape, he sent a detachment to Sorrel. After brief fighting, the British withdrew. Smoke rising from Montreal's chimneys welcomed Montgomery’s troops as they approached the city. A surrender demand failed, however, and as negotiations dragged on, Carleton managed to slip down the St. Lawrence River to the safety of Quebec. On November 13, Montgomery’s exhausted men entered a city without defenders - a Pyrrhic victory. 

Guy Carleton

 Back in Montreal, Montgomery insisted that the captured British prisoners be treated kindly. After all, many of them were not long before his comrades in arms. However, some of his own officers were unhappy with this. Montgomery was disappointed by another act of indiscipline, and only protests from the commander-in-chief prevented him from resigning.

Quebec

Determined to finish the campaign, Montgomery sailed to Quebec City on November 28 with 300 of his best men. Four days later, he joined forces with Benedict Arnold's remaining men at Pointe aux Trembles, just upriver from Quebec. Montgomery took command of both groups, and his first action was to deliver much-needed clothing and supplies to the exhausted “rabble in arms” marching through the Maine wilderness. But winter was tightening its grip on Canada, forcing him to act swiftly. The next day, his combined force moved downstream and encircled Quebec. On December 7, he sent a letter with an ultimatum, but it was burned by Carleton. Montgomery then tried to win the Canadians over to the cause, but his envoy was arrested. Desperate to reach Les Habitants (the locals), he had his proclamation shot over the city wall with bows and arrows. However, they stayed loyal to their new rulers.

Quebec City was the Key to Canada

Now Montgomery had to do the tough work of a siege. Several mortars began shelling the city, but their shells caused little damage. Undeterred, Montgomery moved another battery onto the Plains of Abraham, the site of the battle that decided the city's fate in the French and Indian War. The guns were closer to the walls but also more exposed. Still, by December 15, Montgomery had his batteries in position. Anxious for a resolution, he once again asked for Carleton’s surrender. When Carleton refused, Montgomery’s batteries opened fire. The guns failed to make an impact and were immediately threatened by effective British counter-battery fire. He was forced to order them back. 

Quebec City and Environs

With supplies running low, morale weakening, and winter approaching, Montgomery had no choice but to storm the city. He decided to attack the Lower Town district (Saint-Roch) on the bank of the Saint Lawrence while Arnold would assault the powerful Cape Diamond Bastion. He planned the attack during a stormy night, hoping the weather would conceal their movement from the British. An attack scheduled for December 27 was canceled when the weather cleared. He was forced to revise his plans after someone defected to the British and revealed his strategies.

Montgomery's situation required 

careful planning and flexibility

Montgomery prepared his plan. He aimed for a two-prong attack on the Lower Town, coming from the south, while Arnold would attack from the north. To mislead the British, Montgomery used a deception tactic. He ordered the 1st Canadian Regiment (local fighters who had joined the American cause) to fire at one of the gates, while a separate group engaged the defenders at Cape Diamond Bastion. The signal for the assault was rocket fire. Montgomery’s unimpressive artillery would bombard the city during the feint attacks. This was a bold and risky move. One Montgomery was reluctant to make, but he had no alternative. As George Washington would face a year later, expiring enlistments were draining the army, and many would be gone by January 1. 

A Night to Remember, and Forget

Montgomery experienced his second snowstorm on the night of December 30. He quickly issued the order. Shivering but now energized, the Americans gathered in the wind and snow. The night was cold, dark, and intense, with wind howling and snow swirling. Where was the signal? At 4 am, an orange burst lit up the sky. Boot steps muffled by the wind and snow as his men made their way to the lower town. However, the British were warned by the rockets, and the walls were well-manned. 

Night attack in a snowstorm

With their general at the front, the Americans edged down the steep and slippery cliffs and arrived just below the city walls. As if they didn't have enough obstacles, a palisade at the edge of the Lower Town now blocked their way! Axemen ran to the front and began chopping through. Then Montgomery personally led his column through the opening. Unknown to Montgomery, he was now a major general, promoted by Congress on December 9 for his victories at St. Johns and Montreal. Seeing a two-story blockhouse blocking their path, he had no time to waste or hesitate. He drew his sword and led the troops toward it, shouting, "Come on, my good soldiers, your general calls upon you to come on."

Quebec's defenders proved formidable

The desperate men gripped their muskets tightly and moved forward. About fifty yards away, an equally determined group of Canadian militia and British sailors in the blockhouse unleashed a barrage of musket balls and grapeshot. Montgomery was hit in the head and both thighs by grapeshot and died instantly. The deadly fire brought down two of his captains.

Death of Montgomery

The attack fell apart after Montgomery’s death. The Americans retreated chaotically. A staff officer named Aaron Burr tried to carry Montgomery’s body back but failed. Meanwhile, Benedict Arnold's attack, which had started well, also broke down when Arnold was wounded in the leg by a ball. Many of his men, including Daniel Morgan, were forced to surrender to the British bayonets. With the guns suddenly silent, the howling wind and snow marked the end of the effort to connect Canada to the American cause. 

Benedict Arnold

Honors in Death

Montgomery was highly respected by the British for his previous service and his humane treatment of prisoners at Montreal. Carleton had him buried modestly but with honor on January 4. Some of his men, now prisoners, watched their beloved and heroic general during the solemn funeral. Meanwhile, Arnold, with a bandaged leg, took command of the battered army. His efforts to save the lost cause would be heroic and extraordinary but ultimately futile.

First Hero – First Monument

News of Richard Montgomery’s death was a heavy blow to the Northern Department. Schuler wrote, "My amiable friend, the gallant Montgomery, is no more; the brave Arnold is wounded; and we have met a severe setback in an unsuccessful attempt on Quebec. May Heaven be graciously pleased that the misfortune may end here." For a time, news of his death was kept quiet to delay the morale decline that would follow.

Phillip Schuyler

Washington was dismayed at the loss. So struck by Montgomery’s valiant death, Congress commissioned a monument to him and held a memorial service. He was celebrated as a hero throughout the colonies – perhaps the nation’s first national hero. 

The Montgomery Monument

Significantly, Montgomery's death was mourned in Britain, and his former Whig allies used his death as an opportunity to criticize British policy. British Prime Minister Lord North acknowledged his qualities as a man but condemned him as a rebel. However, many of the London papers actually paid tribute to Montgomery. 

Lord North

Montgomery’s widow, Janet, dedicated her life to protecting his legacy. She moved to the house near Rhinebeck, which she had initially hoped to keep before the war. She also rejected a marriage proposal from former Continental general and British officer Horatio Gates. This was noteworthy in a society where widows usually remarried. 

Final Farewell

In 1818, Governor Stephen van Rensselaer of New York had Montgomery's body moved to New York. About 5,000 mourners participated in his funeral procession, and on July 8, he was laid to rest for the last time next to the Montgomery monument at St. Paul’s Church. The ceremony provided some closure for Janet Montgomery, who was pleased with the honors given to the soldier she loved.

In closing, Montgomery, Alabama, named after America's first hero, unveiled a statue of its namesake in 2019 as part of its bicentennial celebration. It is somehow touching that a man who died in the cold of the North would be honored by citizens in the deep South. 

Montgomery statue in Alabama